I'm usually a little wary of cheap polish because I worry about potentially toxic ingredients, so this display of Confetti nail polish at CVS really caught my attention. It's advertised as 3 free (no toluene, formaldehyde, or DBP) and it's only $1.99 a bottle! I read online that the manufacturer is being sued by Sally Hansen so they'll likely be discontinued when the displays run out. I was really impressed with the first two bottles I tried so I went back over the weekend and picked up a bunch of colors that might be promising. .
Here's a quick wheel of the colors I bought; I'll try to post swatches soon in case anyone else is interested in picking them up at CVS while they last:
One piece of advice though, make sure to open the bottle and check out the brush before you purchase. Some of the bottles have defective brushes--it looks like they were a little too long so they got bent in the bottle. Not great quality control, but for $1.99 a bottle I'm willing to put in a little extra effort to check each bottle before I buy.
If you accidentally buy a bottle with a defective brush or decide you don't like a color, don't forget that CVS has a 100% beauty satisfaction guarantee and you can return opened products with no questions asked as long as you have the receipt. Also if you sign up for their free Extracare Beauty Club you get 10% off your first beauty purchase, $5 back for every $50 spent on beauty products, and $3 on your birthday.